Is it true that tube amps have to be played loudly in order to sound good?
- AMP1 Mercury Edition
- AMP1 Iridium Edition
- AMP1 Silver Edition
- The Sound Finder
- BluBOX VSC
- Electric Guitar Wiki
- Fix it yourself
- Web shop, returns & service
You often hear - and can read again and again - that guitar amps, especially tube amps, have to be played loudly in order to sound good... or, conversely, that tube amps don't sound good when played softly. Since this very generalized statement is not true, we would like to take a closer look at the topic and give you a few pointers as to where this statement comes from and what is true - and what is not.
What's your sound ideal?
With regard to a certain sound ideal, it is true that a tube amp sounds better when it is turned up so far that the power amplifier begins to compress and go to saturation: the vintage sounds of the 60s and 70s were created in this way. Full and round tone, singing overtones and fat lead sounds are the result of power amp compression. It is a widespread - but equally false - rumor that a good guitar sound always needs power amp compression.
Is it really vintage or more modern?
Rather, this is most likely to apply to the vintage sounds mentioned above, but less to more modern guitar sounds. After all, anyone who has ever heard and, above all, felt power amp compression will find that it is also characterized by fluttering, loose bass and may be "harder" to play. Not all guitarists like this!
Another sound ideal has established itself in modern guitar sounds: the tones have become tighter and tighter. Compressive distortion devices such as the Tube Screamer are placed in front of the amp, and the amp's clean channel is often used as a pedal platform. Output stage saturation becomes less important and is often even undesirable.
With the Mesa/Boogie Dual Recifier, for example, which played a key role in shaping the nu-metal sound of the late 90s and early 00s, the output stage was usually switched from tube rectifiers to silicon rectifiers because it then reacts more tightly. In this way, the sound ideal of modern rock and metal sounds comes closer into view.
Underestimated sound component: the guitar cabinet!
In addition, the overall sound of a guitar amplifier always consists of an amp and speaker cabinet. The cab makes a significant contribution to the overall sound! The loudspeaker cabinet also plays an important role in terms of the volume at which an amp sounds good or not.
There are loudspeakers that - due to their relatively heavy membrane and a relatively large voice coil - overemphasize the highs at low volume, and therefore sound unbalanced. They only sound round and pleasant at higher volumes.
Speakers with a lighter diaphragm and a smaller voice coil diameter, on the other hand, sound round and balanced even at low volume. In addition to old Celestion Greenbacks, all BluGuitar loudspeakers, for example, also have this feature.
Ultimately, in order for a loudspeaker to sound alive, it needs a certain amount of stress. A 4x12" cab with 100 watts of power (or more) does not sound particularly lively if it is loaded with 10 watts from the amp, because the speakers hardly move. A 1x12" cab with a lower output, on the other hand, starts to sound lively much earlier.
So you have to differentiate here too: depending on the performance of a cab and the type and number of speakers, there are guitar cabs that sound unbalanced and stiff when played quietly - but also those that show their liveliness even at low volumes and sound pleasantly round and fat.